There comes a point about two-thirds of the way through “Tallulah” wherein a character begins asking some sensible questions, only to be cut off and scolded by another character. The film, which is the first for director Sian Heder, is not bad, It has, in fact, two or three excellent scenes, mostly courtesy of Allison Janney (who gets my vote for the world’s finest actor).
Ellen Page stars as Tallulah, a scrappy kid who lives out of a van with her boyfriend (Evan Jonigkeit). Page, who is tiny, is an actor whose intensity and instincts nonetheless stand tall. Page plays Tallulah, who kidnaps a baby from a farcically inept mother, as a young woman who projects strength and sass, a sort of unwashed enfant terrible, but who is dying on the inside. Tallulah’s zeal for stealing and scamming always seems just about to give way to anguished sobbing.
After Dino (the boyfriend) skips out on Tallulah, she finds her way to New York City and the doorstep of Dino’s mother, Margo (Janney), who summarily shuts the door in Lu’s face. After a plot contrivance, Lu returns, this time with the stolen baby, which she presents to Margo as her granddaughter, gaining both of them admittance. The film takes its time setting this premise up because it’s also arranging a series of plot dominoes it plans to knock down later.
“Tallulah,” like its characters, wears its emotions, and its thematic interests, on its sleeve. Characters state outright what ought be left implicit. Yet Heder, who also wrote the screenplay, has a knack for casting, arranging actors like Page, Zachary Quinto, and Uzo Aduba in small but poignant roles. Watching “Tallulah,” one wishes those roles were a bit more reasonable — characters we know to be smart reliably behave in dopey ways. A short chase scene through a subway station, like the film’s premise, relies on Margo, whom we know to be an intelligent and deep-thinking woman, behaving like a gullible moron.
With its budget of six-million dollars, “Tallulah” is an average-quality indie that could’ve been a disaster with lesser actors. Page and Janney take average dialogue and turn it into gold. The film is worth watching for these performances, particularly Janney, who transforms a simple scene of a pet turtle dying into a clinic for actors everywhere.
“Tallulah” — TWO STARS
Directed by Sian Heder. Rated R. Route One Entertainment, Ocean Blue Entertainment, Netflix. 111 min.